Film Review
Judging by its unflattering portrayal in films over the past few
decades, the French education system is in a pretty bad way.
Le
Maître d'école (1981),
P.R.O.F.S.
(1985),
Le Plus beau métier du monde
(1996) and
L'École pour tous (2006)
all paint the same depressing picture of anarchy in the classroom, into
which an idealistic young teacher wades like a modern Daniel checking
into the lion's den.
Entre
les murs is the latest addition to this well-worn genre and,
whilst its subject is woefully familiar, it stands out from the rest
because it avoids the tired clichés, forced romanticism and
tacky moralising, but instead shows things as they really
are.
Occupying the hazy middle-ground between documentary and social drama,
the film offers no solutions to the failings of the current education
system and does not attempt to make any profound moral or political
point. It merely draws our attention to what is becoming a
serious social problem, namely how can a teacher do his job effectively
when he no longer has the respect of his class and when the class
comprises such a socially and racially diverse mix that conflict is
inevitable.
Entre les murs is an inspired
adaptation of François Bégaudeau's acclaimed 2006 novel
of the same title, winner of the Prix France
Culture-Télérama, in which the writer draws on his own
experiences as a teacher at a school in a rough area of Paris.
Bégaudeau plays a fictional version of himself in the film, a
flawed but likeable teacher whose efforts to win over his class are
constantly thwarted by their lippy indifference and his own
character failings.
The film was enthusiastically received by the critics when it was first
released and was awarded the Palme d'Or at Cannes in 2008, the first
French film to win the coveted prize since Maurice Pialat's
Sous le soleil de Satan in
1987. It was also honoured at the 2009 Césars, winning an
award for its screenplay and being nominated in four other categories,
including Best Film and Best Director.
This is Laurent Cantet's fourth full-length film to date and
stylistically resembles his stunning first feature,
Ressources humaines (1999), a
hard-edged docu-drama revolving around confrontation in the
workplace.
Entre les murs
isn't quite as bleak as this earlier film and there are some lighter
moments, yet it doesn't shirk from showing the grim reality of life in
an inner city classroom. The naturalistic performances and
Cantet's understated mise-en-scène give the film a realism that
allows us to appreciate the frustration of both the teacher and his
pupils as they endure an ordeal which looks less like an education and
more like a pointless ritual of psychological attrition imposed by the state.
The class that we see in this film - a diverse mix that is comprised
entirely of non-professional actors - shows what many teachers face,
day in, day out: a hoard of savvy, outspoken individuals who just do
not see the point of education. Is their teacher,
François, a hero or a deluded masochist? Just how can he
hope to sell something as nebulous as the imperfect subjunctive to a
bunch of semi-illiterates who wll probably never so much as look at a
book after leaving school?
Entre les murs is a
thought-provoking and humane piece of drama that highlights some
deep-seated flaws in today's education system. Whether it will
actually change anything remains to be seen.
© James Travers 2010
The above content is owned by filmsdefrance.com and must not be copied.
Next Laurent Cantet film:
Ressources humaines (1999)