The 1920s was the decade in which French cinema was at its most uninhibited
and extravagant. Costly adaptations of literary works
dominated commercial cinema, whilst the leading figures of the avant-garde
(Abel Gance, Marcel L'Herbier, René Clair and Jean
Epstein) continued the pioneering work of the previous decade,
extending the language of film art. Before sound came along
in the last years of the decade, cinema
became ever more sophisticated in its visual representation of
the world, often blurring the boundaries between reality and imagination.
In spite of strong competition from Hollywood,
French cinema held its own and was never more dazzling that in the last years
of the silent era.
Here are some of the highlights of French cinema from the 1920s.
For a more complete list consult our best films index and complete films index.
L'Hirondelle et la mésange (1920)
L'Hirondelle et la mésange is the most groundbreaking film
that the avant-garde director André Antoine made but it was thought
too documentary-like to be a commercial proposition and so was shelved after
it was filmed in 1920. It wasn't until 1982 that the film's rushes
were rediscovered by the Cinémathèque française.
Edited by Henri Colpi, the film was first screened in 1984 and was instantly
hailed as a masterpiece.
L'Homme du large, Marcel L'Herbier's first notable film, provides
an intensely compelling portrayal of the forces of good and evil that motivate
human behaviour. It may not have the epic scale and bold artistry of
the director's later films, but it is a masterwork of cinematic storytelling
and uses a dazzling range of innovative photographic techniques to dazzle
its audience.
El Dorado was one of first successes of the great avant-garde filmmaker
Marcel L'Herbier. It is a mesmerising piece of cinema, despite its melodramatic
subject, and it never ceases to impress with the sublime artistry that its
director lavishes on it. The film resonates with its vivid expressions of
intense primal emotions, which range from the anguish of a mother unable
to cure her dying son and the blind terror of an attempted rape.
Fièvre is one of the finest achievements
of the avant-garde pioneer Louis Delluc, and whilst it is a short film, it
is a defining work in French cinema. Set mostly in a Marseille bar
that is crowded with debauched sailors and their floozies, it contains within
it the seeds of so many great films to come - from the Provençal dranas
of Marcel Pagnol to the atmospheric poetic realist works of Julien Duvivier
and Marcel Carné, even prefiguring film noir.
The humanist pioneer Jacques Feyder soon established himself as one of France's
leading filmmakers with this grand adaptation of Pierre Benoît's famous
novel L'Atlantide. This was an extraordinarily
ambitious production for its time, since Feyder insisted on it being shot
on location in North Africa rather than in a sand quarry in France.
The film took just under a year to complete and rivals the more ambitious
Hollywood productions of the time.
Henri Diamant-Berger's insanely ambitious 1921 production of Les Trois
mousquetaires is both a superlative example of silent cinema, stylishly
shot and edited with great flair, and a rollicking good action-adventure film.
In its day, this was one of the most lavish and spectacular of the episodic
serials to have been made in France, surpassing earlier series by Louis Feuillade
in its scale and artistic vision. It remains one if the finest adaptations
of Dumas's famous literary work.
In its day, Quatre-vingt-treize was one of the most expensive films
ever to have been made in France - and it shows. This lavish superproduction
offers a spectacular visualisation of Victor Hugo's monumental critique of
the French Revolution. The scale of the project was mind-boggling for
the time, yet director Albert Capellani was more than up to the challenge
of delivering a three hour epic intended to be the greatest film ever made
in France.
Jacques Feyder's reputation as one of France's leading filmmakers of his
day was established early in the 1920s with such films as this masterful
adaptation of a popular short novel by Anatole France. Crainquebille is a fairly modest piece, combining social
drama and punchy satire, but one that is extraordinarily direct and engaging.
The film's subject matter fits perfectly with Feyder's rigorously naturalistic
style of filmmaking.
On paper, Coeur fidèle is nothing more than
a trite melodrama, of the kind that was prevalent in cinema in the early
1920s. What the avant-garde director Jean Epstein does with this film
is far more important than its characters and the story it tells. His
intention was to show that by employing his well-developed theories of cinema
it was possible to elevate the vulgar art of melodrama to something of far
greater merit, achieving a nearer approximation to real life than any other
form of art.
'A tragedy for modern times' is how the great cinema pioneer Abel Gance
promoted his epic masterpiece La Roue, although
he could equally have described it as an intimate, realist melodrama painted
on a canvas of gigantic proportions. No one who watches the film can
fail to be taken aback by the sheer scale of Gance's insane ambition.
More importantly, the film introduces innovative techniques that would have
a wide-ranging and lasting impact on the medium of film.
L'Auberge rouge is a comparatively minor work in Jean Epstein's oeuvre,
a low-key crime-drama that gave the 25-year-old director the opportunity to
experiment with the impressionistic techniques that were being deployed, with
some success, by his contemporaries. With its overt 'greed is bad'
moral it is tempting to read an anti-capitalist, anti-bourgeois subtext into
L'Auberge rouge, and this would certainly chime with the director's
own leftwing sympathies. Not Epstein's greatest film, but one of his most
experimental.
Le Miracle des loups has been described as the
French equivalent to America's The Birth of a Nation
(1915) and the influence of D.W. Griffith is apparent in the film's elaborate
and astonishingly convincing battle sequences. After its premiere at
the Paris Opéra in 1924, the film went on to become a major critical
and commercial success. One reviewer who didn't think much of it was
Abel Gance, who dismissed it as a bad film lacking in both art and drama.
Gance was wrong on both counts.
The first impression that L'Inhumaine makes is
the boldly geometric nature of every aspect of its design. Cubism and
Art Deco are the strongest influences, employed with great artistry in the
construction of the interior and exterior sets. The film looks like
a mad explosion of art purely for art's sake, but it also tells a gripping
story. In his attempt to forge a new kind of cinema director Marcel L'Herbier
is at his most inventive, unwittingly laying the foundation for a new genre
of film, the science-fiction fantasy.
A recurring motif of Jean Epstein's, the untamed ageless sea, punctuates
the prosaic narrative of Le Double amour in a way
that eerily prefigures the lyrical Breton phase at the end of the director's
remarkable career. Cosmic repetition is the film's other central theme,
the idea that people are condemned to repeat the same patterns of behaviour,
again and again, like marionettes in the hands of some celestial influence.
The story may be that of a fairly routine melodrama, but Epstein makes
it a far more profound work.
Les Aventures de Robert Macaire shows little of
the wild flair for invention and stylistic bravado that define so much of
Jean Epstein's other work but it is an accomplished piece of commercial filmmaking
that impresses as much with its meticulous shot composition as with the quality
of the acting. Some flashback sequences allow the director to depart
from the linear narrative and toy mischievously with the idea of the unreliable
witness.
Although it looks modest compared with many well-regarded silent films of
its period, Paris qui dort is nonetheless a film of considerable importance.
It is the first film of the celebrated French film director, René
Clair, and also - although it was not seen as such at the time - the first
fully fledged science-fiction movie. The film is best remembered for
its stunning sequences filmed on the Eiffel Tower.
The 1925 version of Poil de carotte was director
Julien Duvivier's first notable success. It may be less well-known
and less well-regarded than his subsequent sound films, but it stands apart
from Duvivier's other silent films both in its artistry and its humanity.
The director was so fond of this film that he later remade it as a
sound film. The darker aspects that we see in Duvivier's later films
are more than evident in this emotionally engaging early work.
Feu Mathias Pascal is by far the most conventional
and accessible of Marcel L'Herbier's silent films, an enjoyable mélange
of farce and melodrama that shows a much lighter side to the director than
is seen in his better known works. The streak of exuberant comedy that
runs through the film evokes something of Ernst Lubitsch's early silent offerings,
and many of the gags would not be out of place in a Buster Keaton or Marx
Brothers film.
No other filmmaker directed children better than Jacques Feyder, and the
truth of this is at once apparent in his touching realist melodrama Gribiche.
Jean Forest was just nine years old when Feyder found him by chance playing
in the streets of Paris. The enchanting little boy was a gift to celluloid.
Based on a novel of the same title by Frédéric Boutet, Gribiche
was the first and best of the three films that Feyder made for the prestigious
Albatros film company.
Le Voyage imaginaire completes a trilogy of highly
imaginative silent fantasies which director René Clair made at the
very start of his illustrious filmmaking career. Whilst it borrows
some elements from Clair's previous two films - Le Fantôme
du Moulin-Rouge (1925) and Paris qui dort
(1925) - it is a more ambitious and exuberant piece, with boisterous doses
of slapstick accompanying the director's most eccentric flight of fancy.
Ménilmontant is a masterpiece of film impressionism,
one of the most captivating cinematic gems created by the avant-garde pioneer
Dimitri Kirsanoff. Whereas many of the films
of the Parisian avant-garde of the 1920s now appear pretentious, florid or
lacking in artistic coherence, this exquisite film has a reality and solidity
that make it an intensely absorbing human drama as well as an incredibly
daring piece of film art.
Of the many screen adaptations of the works of Jules Verne few are as visually
spectacular and memorable as Victor Tourjansky's stunning silent epic Michel Strogoff. Running to almost three hours in length,
Tourjansky's film was a bold testament to the ambition and confidence of
French cinema at the height of its Golden Age in the 1920s, a lavish production
that has all the drama, excitement and compulsion of Verne's classic novel.
The second feature to be directed by the great innovator Jean Renoir was
this lavish adaptation of Emile Zola's classic novel, Nana.
The film can hard fail to impress with its insane extravagances, which include
vast overly decorated sets and two magnificent set-pieces - a horse race
and an open air ball (complete with a lively cancan sequence). So much
money was spent on this film that it could never have returned a profit,
and it was the commercial failure of this film which robbed Renoir of the
opportunity to make such an ambitious film again for many years.
Of the films that director Jean Epstein made, La Glace à trois faces is the
one that was most enthusiastically received on its original release. In
both narrative and visual terms, it is the most innovative and daring of
the director's films, breaking many of the rules of cinema at the time and
creating some new ones for future directors. This priceless masterwork
had a huge impact on the filmmakers of the French New Wave era, including
Alain Resnais and Chris Marker.
In later years René Clair would be dismissive of La Proie du vent.
He may have resented making the film - the plot is pure melodrama with few
narrative surprises - but Clair had ample opportunity to foist on it his
avant-garde credentials and, in doing so, he crafts one of his more intimate
and humane works. With a captivating central performance from Charles
Vanel, this is one of the director's most emotionally involving films.
Le Joueur d'échecs is one of the great cinematic
achievements of the silent era, a sumptuous blend of historical wartime epic,
romantic fantasy and farce. The film was directed by Raymond Bernard, an
immensely inventive filmmaker who enjoyed considerable commercial success,
and is based on a novel by Henri Dupuy-Mazuel, inspired by the true story
of a chess-playing automaton named 'The Turk', the baffling creation of the
Hungarian baron Wolfgang von Kempelen.
L'Invitation au voyage is the work of Germaine Dulac,
the most prominent feminist writer, artist and filmmaker of her time.
One of the avant-garde experimentalists of the 1920s, Duluc saw film as a
new art form for expressing ideas and conveying images in a way which would
be impossible or inappropriate in other artistic media. Her films are
both fascinating expressions of female desire and stunningly inventive pieces
of film art.
Ever since the film was first seen, Abel Gance's epic Napoléon
has been hailed as one of the true landmarks in cinema history, a film of
breathtaking vision and extraordinary cinematographic bravura. The
impressionistic techniques that Gance had employed so brilliantly on earlier
films are used to their fullest effect to create a cinema experience that
was unrivalled in its day and still packs an almighty punch today. According
to some, this is the greatest film ever made..
As a journey into the realm of unbridled fantasy, La Chute
de la maison is pretty well unsurpassed by any other film of the silent
era. The repeated tracking shots and bold use of superimposition,
the desolate mist-laden exteriors and the fact that not everything we see
makes sense logically all have the same effect - to persuade the spectator
that he is experiencing a dream rather than watching a film. The pinnacle
of Jean Epstein's cinematic achievement, this film was to be massively influential
in the gestation of the American horror film.
A good candidate for the weirdest film ever made, La Coquille
et le clergyman was the product of two mutually incompatible creative
talents of the 1920s - the writer Antonin Artaud and the feminist filmmaker
Germaine Dulac. Steeped in Freudian imagery, it is about one man's
inner battle against his lustful thoughts. The images range from the
explicit (a wide-eyed priest ripping off a woman's bra) to the obvious visual
metaphors - such as a man unlocking an endless series of doors. A genuinely
unsettling work.
Acknowledged as one of the essential masterpieces of silent French cinema,
Carl Theodor Dreyer's La Passion de Jeanne d'Arc
still has the power move and beguile. It is a sublime
example of transcendent cinema that offers the spectator
a unique visual and emotional experience. There is an astonishing humanity
to this film that is harrowing in its intensity and yet also spiritually cleansing.
With its masterful use of large close-ups to convey the unbearable agony of Joan
of Arc as she is tried and condemned, Dreyer's unique film hits us more powerfully
than any other work of film art.
At a cost of nearly five million francs, L'Argent was Marcel L'Herbier's
most lavish and greatest film. Based on a novel of the same title by
Emile Zola, but updated to contemporary France, the fillm makes a flagrant
and fierce condemnation on the world of high finance, particularly the unpardonable
sin of speculation. Thanks to its modern setting and simple story of
greed and corruption, this remarkable film is just as relevant today as it
was in the late 1920s.
René Clair's skilful transposition of Eugène Labiche's popular
play Un chapeau de paille d'Italie from the 1850s
to the 1890s provides an irresistibly hilarious satire on bourgeois attitudes
and is as entertaining today as it was when it was first seen in the 1920s.
With its humorous characters and engaging morality play this is the
most accessible and enjoyable of Clair's great films.
Finis Terrae is not a straightforward documentary but rather a drama
filmed in a documentary style. Prefiguring the startlingly naturalistic
films he would later make in Brittany, this film marked a dramatic change
for the avant-garde cineaste Jean Epstein, away from the studios of Paris
to a location renowned for its raw and unprepossessing landscape. An
intensely involving piece of cinema it is replete with stark yet inexpressibly
beautiful images that show the dual character of Man and Nature at its worst
and most benign.
The last of the monstrously ambitious superproductions of the silent era,
Henri Fescourt's Monte Cristo is easily one of cinema's
best adaptations of A lexandre Dumas's celebrated novel. The artistic
quality and scale ofthe film are simply breathtaking. This is silent
cinema at its most ambitious, most perfect, a last great parting shot before
the arrival of sound would consign silent films to history for ever.
A collaboration between two masters of surrealist art - Luis Buñuel
and Salvador Dalí - Un chien andalou is
a full-on assault against bourgeois conformity and contains some of the weirdest
- and most shocking - images that cinema has given us, including the notorious
eyeball-slitting sequence. If you can make any sense of this cinematic
oddity you almost certainly haven't been watching it closely enough.