Film Review
The much-publicised "sequel" to Mathieu Kassovitz's popular 2000 film
Les Rivières pourpres
takes the big budget Grand Guignol spectacle of guns and gore up
several notches whilst happily flushing virtually every last ounce of
charm, realism and artistic merit down the
toilet. Jean Reno is back for a second round of mindless
no-strings thuggery, this time paired with Benoît Magimel, whose
casting as a replacement for Vincent Cassel makes about as much sense
as replacing Darth Vader with Kermit the Frog in the second Star Wars
film. Heaven alone knows what induced Christopher Lee to
sign up for a part in this cinematic monstrosity - one suspects that
witchcraft, demonic powers and the might of the Inland Revenue may have
been involved.
Before he won almost universal acclaim for his direction of the 2007
Edith Piaf biopic
La Môme, Olivier Dahan
was not considered that seriously in France. Whatever credibility
he had gained with his early directorial offerings -
Déjà
mort (1998) and
La Vie promise (2002) - was
virtually decimated by his work on
Les
Rivières pourpres II. Whilst some critics praised
Dahan for his daring reinterpretation of the adventure thriller genre,
many more were spouting invective, sarcasm and vile in the way that
only French film critics and British tabloid journalists know how to.
Whatever else may be said about
Les
Rivières pourpres II, it certainly makes a strong visual
statement, albeit in much the same way as a clout on the head
with a garden spade does. The gauzy, low resolution digital photography gives
the film a distinctive dreamlike character which, visually at least,
makes the film more interesting than its predecessor.
Unfortunately, Dahan and his team get well and truly carried away and
the surfeit of artistic style quickly becomes tedious and
migraine-inducing.
The plot, what there is of it (something about
flying bullet-proof monks prosecuting a bloody vendetta
against people with religious first names whilst helping Christopher
Lee on his treasure hunt), is something
that the average nine-year-old would dismiss as childish.
And whatever characterisation there might be lurking in the crevices of
the festering morass of mediocrity that goes by the name of a
screenplay is swept away and drowned in a record-breaking tsunami of
stylistic excess.
Les
Rivières pourpres II is silly but, worse than that, it takes itself far
too seriously to be fun. A propos, that scene in the supermarket (in
which a group of Dominican hoodies go on an eco-friendly two-for-the-price-of-one killing spree)
is pretty mild compared with what you see in Tesco's on most Saturday mornings...
© James Travers 2008
The above content is owned by filmsdefrance.com and must not be copied.
Next Olivier Dahan film:
La Môme (2007)
Film Synopsis
In a monastery in Lorraine, a monk is nailing a crucifix onto a stone
wall when blood begins to flow..... Behind the wall,
the body of a dead man is found. Investigating the case,
Commissaire Pierre Niemans suspects this may not be an ordinary
murder. He is right. A young police captain Reda has just
prevented the killing of a man resembling Jesus Christ. But other
murders follow in quick and spectacular fashion, and it can hardly be a
coincidence that each victim carries the name of one of Christ's
disciples...
© James Travers
The above content is owned by filmsdefrance.com and must not be copied.