Film Review
Whatever artistic genius Abel Gance was able to call upon in the early years of his film
making career had all but dissipated by the time he came to make this run-of-the-mill
pseudo-historical. Made at the time of the Nazi Occupation of France (albeit in
studios in the Free Zone which were not directly under Nazi control), Gance's creativity
was restricted both financially and politically.
The film was intended to be escapist fun for the masses, not an avant-garde masterpiece,
and in this respect the film hit its mark. Although condemned by the critics, the
film was popular with the French people, offering a welcome release from the privations
of their wartime experiences. However, Gance's reputation and confidence took a
pounding and it would be more than a decade before he could complete his next film.
Whilst Gance's direction is, as ever, technically competent, it is largely uninspired,
as though the author had little interest in the subject of his film. Indeed, from
the frequent references to another historical tale (Cyrano de Bergerac), Gance gives the
impression that he would rather be making a different film. Despite this,
and despite the overly theatrical performances (justified by the fact that the story is
about theatrical people), the film has an indefinable charm. The crowded baroque
sets and Nicholas Hayer's near-expressionist photography give the film the feel
of a dark poetic fantasy, similar to Jean Cocteau's
La Belle et la bête (1946).
This is most apparent in the film's last fifteen or so minutes in which Gance finally
manages to impose his artistic style with a beautifully crafted denouement, saving what
might otherwise have been dismissed as a lacklustre piece of cinematic theatre.
Even in the dismal protracted sunset of his career, Abel Gance was still able to surprise
his detractors with a few fleeting moments of naked artistic brilliance.
© James Travers 2004
The above content is owned by filmsdefrance.com and must not be copied.
Next Abel Gance film:
La Tour de Nesle (1955)
Film Synopsis
Penniless and alone, the young
Baron of Cigognac is ready
to join his ancestors in the family vault beneath his run-down chateau. Then, unexpectedly,
a group of travelling actors arrive at his home and ask for shelter for one night.
The baron welcomes the travellers into his home and immediately falls in love with one
of them, a beautiful ingénue named Isabelle. The next day, the actors persuade
the Baron to travel with them as far as Paris. On the way, one of the actors dies
and the Baron agrees to take his place, assuming the name Capitain Fracasse. During
one of their performances, Isabelle attracts the attention of the Duke of Vallombreuse.
The ensuing rivalry between the Baron and the Duke is settled in a duel, which the Baron
wins. Intent on revenge, the Duke sends his henchmen to kill the Baron in an ambush.
The attack fails, but Isabelle is captured and taken to the Duke's chateau.
There, the Duke and the Baron confront each other in a duel to the death. To save
the Baron, Isabelle agrees to marry the Duke, not knowing that she is in fact the Duke's
long-lost sister…
© James Travers
The above content is owned by filmsdefrance.com and must not be copied.