Film Review
The trauma of adolescence and the fraught relationship between
children and their parents are two themes that are central to the work
of film director Claude Miller. After
L'Effrontée
(1985),
La Petite voleuse (1988),
L'Accompagnatrice (1992) and
La Classe de neige (1998),
Miller presents his bleakest, most unsettling portrait of teenage
alienation and rebellion, working in collaboration with his son
Nathan. The story is taken from a real-life case and is tackled
in a more naturalist vein than Miller's previous films, not too far
removed from the style of the Dardenne brothers. This is Nathan
Miller's first feature as a director; he had previously worked as a
camera operator on some of his father's films -
Betty
Fisher (2001) and
La Petite Lili (2003) - and
directed a short film,
La Tartine
(2000).
Whilst
Je suis heureux que ma
mère soit vivante is a powerfully authentic piece of
drama, its impact is slightly diminished by a fragmented narrative
structure that is initially confusing. Much of the story is told
using flashbacks, in a way that makes it difficult for the spectator to
engage with the main protagonist. It doesn't help that there is
also an obvious conflict of styles (which presumably reflects the
alternative approaches favoured by the two directors). The film
looks as if it cannot make up its mind whether to go for full-blown
cinéma vérité
realism or stick with a more conventional approach. As
Claude Miller was a close associate of director François
Truffaut (working with him as a production manager on several of his
films). it is perhaps not surprising that the film should have echoes
of Truffaut's
Les 400 coups (1959).
Although the film's fragmented structure and clash of styles is a
little off-putting, these do (serendipitously) serve to highlight the
fractured identity of the main character, Thomas, the youngster who is
obsessed with finding his biological mother. It soon becomes
apparent that Thomas's main motivation for finding his mother is so
that he can work out who he is and thereby ease the transition to
adulthood. He is not really looking for his mother; he is
actually looking for his own true self. His mother's ambivalent
feelings for her son naturally exacerbate his cracked identity, fuel
his deep-seated feelings of rejection and insecurity and, inevitably,
propel the story towards a shockingly dramatic climax.
If the film holds together at all, this probably has more to do with
the contributions from the leading actors than from the combined
efforts of the two directors. Sophie Cattani and Christine Citti
both turn in harrowingly truthful performances as the two mothers, both
afflicted with crippling character defects which make it impossible for
them to establish any kind of meaningful rapport with Thomas, and
Maxime Renard makes a superb debut as the 12-year old Thomas. As
strong as the ensemble is, there is one actor who stands out.
That actor is Vincent Rottiers, who brings a sinister and brooding
intensity to his portrayal of the thoroughly mixed up adult
Thomas. You cannot be sure whether his character is a victim
looking for a way out of his own personal Hell or a deranged psychopath
who is looking for someone to torment. Rottiers previously
distinguished himself in Christophe Ruggia's
Les
Diables (2002) and Xavier Giannoli's
À
l'origine (2009) and is emerging as one of France's finest
young film actors.
© James Travers 2010
The above content is owned by filmsdefrance.com and must not be copied.
Next Claude Miller film:
Thérèse Desqueyroux (2012)
Film Synopsis
Thomas was four when he and his younger brother were adopted by Yves
and Annie Jouvet. When he is twelve, he becomes obsessed with
finding his biological mother, Julie. Thomas's adopted parents
become concerned when he starts behaving aggressively and have no
choice but to help him. Thomas finally manages to track down his
birth mother, but naturally she does not recognise him.
Disgusted, the boy runs off without telling her who he is. Eight
more years pass before Thomas has the courage to confront Julie and
tell her that he is her son...
© James Travers
The above content is owned by filmsdefrance.com and must not be copied.