Film Review
David Lean's epic saga of romance and revolution in Russia has been
vilified as much as it has been praised. Some consider it a
masterpiece, possibly Lean's best film (but only by those
who have never seen
Oliver Twist
or
Lawrence of Arabia);
others dismiss it as overblown
artistic self-indulgence. Lean's most expensive film,
Doctor Zhivago is a faithful
rendering of Boris Pasternak's sprawling novel and certainly impresses
with its wondrous visuals - its stunning snow-filled panoramas of the
Russian landscape (filmed in Canada and Finland) and authentic,
well-choreographed action sequences. Maurice Jarre evocative
score includes the haunting
Lara's
Theme, one of the most famous pieces of music in cinema history.
Yet the film is far from perfect. It is uncomfortably overlong,
the pace painfully uneven and Omar Sharif so obviously miscast in the
lead role. Watching
Doctor
Zhivago without a comfort break is like subjecting yourself to a
long and bumpy journey on the Trans-Siberian Railway - the pictures are
pretty, but you can't help getting slightly bored after the first hour
and, boy, is it hard on the posterior. Broken down into three one
hour-long doses (and with a soft cushion), it is much more bearable.
Like Lean's subsequent
Ryan's Daughter (1970),
the film is just too grand for the story it has to tell.
Aesthetically,
Doctor Zhivago
is a work of immense beauty (veering only occasionally to the
unpardonably pretentious), but it fails as a piece of drama.
Despite some creditable performances (Rod Steiger and Tom Courtenay are
excellent), it is hard to engage with the characters or their
plight. We are at least spared the sight of Sophia Loren as Lara
(that was Carlo Ponti's first choice for the role), but Julie Christie
does little with the part other than make her look pretty and
helpless. Had the writers applied more rigour and the
Occam's razor principle the story might have had more impact and less
ennui. Whilst you may watch the film once and appreciate its
cinematographic brilliance, it is unlikely that you will be encouraged
to subject yourself to it a second time, unless you are a masochist
with a short memory.
© James Travers 2009
The above content is owned by filmsdefrance.com and must not be copied.
Next David Lean film:
Ryan's Daughter (1970)
Film Synopsis
After the death of his mother, 8-year-old Yuri Zhivago is adopted by
the bourgeois Gromekos and taken to their home in Moscow. Here,
as he grows into a man, Yuri acquires a love of poetry, but is
determined to make a career as a doctor. He falls in love with
and marries the Gromekos' daughter, Tonya. During WWI, he meets
Lara, the wife of a committed revolutionary, Pasha. On his return
to Moscow, Yuri finds that his house has been seized by the
Bolsheviks. He and his family seek sanctuary from the impending
civil war by fleeing to the country. They settle in a village in
the Urals and lead a peaceful existence until one day Yuri meets Lara
again and realises that he is hopelessly in love with her...
© James Travers
The above content is owned by filmsdefrance.com and must not be copied.