The Lady in Question (1940)
Directed by Charles Vidor

Comedy / Drama / Romance

Film Review

Abstract picture representing The Lady in Question (1940)
Whilst it has some charm, The Lady in Question is one of those frustratingly mercurial films that can't quite make up its mind whether it wants to be a burlesque comedy or a straight melodrama.  It looks suspiciously as if the film started out as a melodrama but, after two or three early drafts of the screenplay, someone (more preoccupied with popularity than artistic integrity) issued the "let's make it funny" edict - hence the rather cumbersome and pretty pointless injections of knockabout comedy.

This is a remake of the 1937 French film Gribouille, which was directed by Marc Allégret and starred Raimu and Michèle Morgan.  Writers Marcel Achard and Lewis Meltzer worked on the screenplay for both films, which explains the close similarity in the plot.  It is telling that the ambiguity and darker aspects of the earlier film are all but lost in its Hollywood remake, which replaces the harsh ending of Gribouille with an unsatisfying and painfully contrived "Happy ever after" coda.

The main appeal of The Lady in Question are the contributions of its high calibre cast.  Rita Hayworth and Glenn Ford appear together, in one of the half a dozen films where they would form a memorable screen duo, although here they are outclassed and outshone by Brian Aherne, who puts in an enjoyably ebullient performance, breathing life into some stillborn comedy.
© James Travers 2008
The above content is owned by filmsdefrance.com and must not be copied.

Film Synopsis

André Morestan, the affable owner of a Parisian bicycle shop, is delighted when he is called for jury service.  An attractive young woman, Natalie Roguin, is on trial for the murder of her boyfriend, and Morestan has no doubt over her innocence.  When Nathalie is acquitted, Morestan offers her a place in his home and a job in his shop, which she accepts gratefully.   Morestan's son Pierre is drawn to the mysterious woman and is resolved to marry her - at any price...
© James Travers
The above content is owned by filmsdefrance.com and must not be copied.


Film Credits

  • Director: Charles Vidor
  • Script: Lewis Meltzer, Marcel Achard (story), Jan Lustig
  • Cinematographer: Lucien N. Andriot
  • Music: Lucien Moraweck
  • Cast: Brian Aherne (Andre Morestan), Rita Hayworth (Natalie Roguin), Glenn Ford (Pierre Morestan), Irene Rich (Michele Morestan), George Coulouris (Defense Attorney), Lloyd Corrigan (Prosecuting Attorney), Evelyn Keyes (Francois Morestan), Edward Norris (Robert LaCoste), Curt Bois (Henri Lurette), Frank Reicher (President), Sumner Getchell (Fat Boy), Nicholas Bela (Nicholas Farkas), Louis Adlon (First Court Clerk), Ronald Alexander (Juror), Leon Belasco (Barber), Mary Bovard (Miss Lucille Morlet), Dorothy Burgess (Antoinette), James B. Carson (Louie Rolande), William Castle (Angry Juror 1), George Davis (Customer)
  • Country: USA
  • Language: English
  • Support: Black and White
  • Runtime: 80 min

The very best American film comedies
sb-img-18
American film comedy had its heyday in the 1920s and '30s, but it remains an important genre and has given American cinema some of its enduring classics.
The very best fantasy films in French cinema
sb-img-30
Whilst the horror genre is under-represented in French cinema, there are still a fair number of weird and wonderful forays into the realms of fantasy.
The very best of German cinema
sb-img-25
German cinema was at its most inspired in the 1920s, strongly influenced by the expressionist movement, but it enjoyed a renaissance in the 1970s.
French cinema during the Nazi Occupation
sb-img-10
Even in the dark days of the Occupation, French cinema continued to impress with its artistry and diversity.
The best of American cinema
sb-img-26
Since the 1920s, Hollywood has dominated the film industry, but that doesn't mean American cinema is all bad - America has produced so many great films that you could never watch them all in one lifetime.
 

Other things to look at


Copyright © filmsdefrance.com 1998-2024
All rights reserved



All content on this page is protected by copyright