Film Review
After gaining admission to the world of filmmaking as a set designer for Marcel L'Herbier, Alberto
Cavalcanti made his directorial debut with this groundbreaking
documentary, which rates as one of his most impressive works.
Although he is best-known for the handful of films he made at Ealing
Studios in the 1940s - British classics that include
Went the Day Well? (1942),
Champagne Charlie (1944) and
Dead
of Night (1945) - Cavalcanti started out as one of the
Parisian avant-garde and for his first film,
Rien que les heures (a.k.a.
Nothing But Time), he embraces the
impressionistic style of his contemporaries - L'Herbier, Abel Gance,
Germaine Dulac, Jean Epstein and Dimitri Kirsanoff. Indeed, it
serves as an effective companion-piece to Kirsanoff's better known
Ménilmontant
(1926), both films providing an unfamiliar and distinctly unromantic
view of the City of Lights.
Rien que les heures is an
early example of a genre of documentary that has come to be known as
the 'city symphony', a kind of film that seeks to draw out the true
ethos of the modern bustling city by examining the relationship between
an urban landscape and the people who inhabit it. Jean Vigo's
À
propos de Nice (1930) is perhaps the best known example of
this genre, and another is Walter Ruttmann's
Die Sinfonie der Großstadt
(1927), a portrait of Berlin to which Cavalcanti lent his
support. Like Vigo's film, Cavalcanti's
Rien que les heures has an
unmistakable anti-bourgeois slant to it and on the few occasions the
bourgeoisie appear on screen it is with an obvious sense of
derision.
At the start of the film, Cavalcanti makes it clear he has no interest
in the fashionable set. A brief shot of a group of young
socialites freezes into a photographic still, which is then torn to
pieces and discarded as worthless trash. Later on, one of the
bourgeois élite is happily consuming a steak. In his
plate, Cavalcanti superimposes the image of cattle being slaughtered
and butchered - an allusion perhaps to the idle rich feeding on the
carcasses of the poor? His appetite for bourgeois-baiting sated,
Cavalcanti can then focus on the more worthy subjects, the hard working
poor and human detritus littering the dreary backstreets of
Paris.
A bent old woman wanders aimlessly before collapsing, laundrywomen toil
without complaint, unemployed men try to fill their empty hours,
a sailor on leave seeks out his girlfriend,
and everywhere tramps are seen lying neglected in the streets.
Occasionally, we are offered a glimpse of the easier life enjoyed by
the better off, but it is Paris's unseen, malodorous underbelly that
interests Cavalcanti most, and having watched the film you feel that
you have seen the true face of the capital, the heart that throbs
beneath the cold marble façade.
© James Travers 2015
The above content is owned by filmsdefrance.com and must not be copied.
Next Alberto Cavalcanti film:
Le Capitaine Fracasse (1929)
Film Synopsis
All cities would look alike if it were not for the monuments which tell
them apart. This is not a depiction of the rich and fashionable
set, but of the poor and downtrodden who eke out modest lives in the
eternal city of Paris. In the slum districts, far from the gaze
of tourists, the narrow streets are awash with tramps, prostitutes and
stray derelicts, whilst honest workers go about their business,
regardless of the wealth being squandered in the city's more salubrious
neighbourhoods. When evening comes and the day's work is done, it
is time for pleasure, but danger lurks in some streets...
© James Travers
The above content is owned by filmsdefrance.com and must not be copied.