Film Review
Ceux d'en face is an unusual film which attempts to get its spectator to regard
the world, or rather human existence, in a new light. Through its innovative use
of photography, music and the spoken word, it offers the kind of spiritual experience
which is rarely encountered in cinema, and to some extent it is an effective and intriguing
work. The film doesn't quite have the impact it could have had - mainly because
it relies too heavily on some unnecessary dramatic devices, principally the unconvincing
rapport between Mikaël and Linda, the only two characters who appear physically on
the screen. The film was directed by Jean-Daniel Pollet, one of the peripheral figures
of the French New Wave, who contributed to the anthology film
Paris vu par... (1965).
Where the film is at its most powerful is where, oddly, it is at its most abstract.
The best example of this are the sequences where the camera pans slowly across a vista
of black and white photographs showing faces of human suffering and joy, accompanied by
some haunting music and a hypnotic voice over. Alain Resnais'
Nuit et brouillard (1955)
and Chris Marker's
Sans soleil (1983)
are brought to mind as the images we see burn
themselves into our consciousness, making us aware of a world out there which we ought
morally to concern ourselves with but which it is too easy to ignore. Unfortunately,
such aristic magic is buried within a rather lame piece of drama involving two singularly
antipathetic and implausible characters (Michael Lonsdale's talents are
pretty well wasted in a role that gives him nothing much to do other
than play the old sage). Had this been made as a shorter, more
abstract film, it might had considerably greater impact. As it is, the film is
strikingly poetic, subtly engaging, but far from satisfying.
© James Travers 2003
The above content is owned by filmsdefrance.com and must not be copied.
Film Synopsis
When her boyfriend, Sébastien, leaves unexpectedly for a voyage of self-discovery
in a distant country, Linda is tasked with collecting his suitcase from a friend, Mikaël,
an ageing composer who lives alone in a remote country house. Mikaël
welcomes Linda's company and invites her to stay until her boyfriend returns. Upon
Sébastien's instructions, Linda sets about arranging a large number of photographs
contained in the mysterious suitcase - photographs which depict human experience across
the world - whilst listening to recorded messages which he sends her periodically. As
she is engaged in this task, Linda undergoes a similar kind of spiritual transformation
to that which her boyfriend has already experienced.
© James Travers
The above content is owned by filmsdefrance.com and must not be copied.